I thought everything was finally taken care of this afternoon and then around 5pm it all went to pot again. The asshats at the hosting co. have really dropped the ball. I couldn't even get into Cpanel at one point. We spent time this evening working on permissions across the server and the various accounts, etc. I'm still getting mail errors as well and have kept AutoTroll offline except when testing to see if mail has come in, and so far nothing has.
Everyone hold on to your turns and keep an eye on this thread. I'll keep you updated as I have new info to share.